Live
Goldman Faces Progressive Challenge Over Israel Support in NY-10
12D AGOUSISRAELNY-10 DEMOCRATIC PRIMARY

Goldman Faces Progressive Challenge Over Israel Support in NY-10

What's the gist?

Rep. Dan Goldman is fighting for his political life against former NYC Comptroller Brad Lander in a heated Democratic primary that has become a referendum on Israel policy and progressive values.

Context

Goldman, who led Trump's first impeachment, won his seat in 2022 by just 1,300 votes with help from his personal wealth and a divided progressive opposition. Now Lander challenges with Mamdani's backing. Both have described themselves as liberal zionists, with Lander saying he supports Israel as a Jewish state where Palestinian rights also thrive. While Lander was Comptroller he ended the city's decades-long, $40 million investment in Israel's sovereign debt. Goldman voted for U.S. military aid to Israel, but also said during the debate that this was not the most crucial issue for the Manhattan-Brooklyn district.

Positive takes

Experienced Fighter. Goldman's impeachment background and committee assignments give him the tools to effectively combat Trump's agenda in Congress.
Immigrant Advocacy. Goldman has freed dozens of unlawfully detained immigrants and opened a triage center overlooking Manhattan's immigration court.
Inclusive Approach. Unlike typical politicians who focus on high-turnout areas, Goldman prioritizes underserved communities like Chinatown that need more help.

Negative takes

Bought Seat. Critics argue Goldman used his inherited Levi Strauss fortune to purchase his congressional seat and remains beholden to wealthy special interests.
Wrong on Gaza. Lander supporters say Goldman's support for military aid to Israel during what they call genocide shows he's out of step with district values.
Corporate Democrat. Progressive activists argue Goldman represents the kind of mainstream Democrat who won't fight hard enough against billionaires and corporate power.
Who are you leaning toward in this race?Pick a candidate to see where New Yorkers stand